Home › Desserts

Desserts

Make your next meal memorable with one or more of our tasty Amish pies. No one will ever guess that you bought your homemade pie online. We'll keep it our little secret.

Whoopie Pie Sampler

$27.99
Shoofly Pie

From: $14.99

To: $22.98
Pecan Pie

From: $14.99

To: $22.98
2 Dozen Snickerdoodle Cookies

$15.99
2 Dozen Peanut Butter Cookies

$15.99

2 Dozen Molasses Cookies

$15.99
2 Dozen Chocolate Chip Cookies

$15.99
12 Peanut Butter Whoopie Pies

$27.99
12 Chocolate Whoopie Pies

$27.99
2 Dozen Cookie Sampler

$15.99