For guaranteed delivery by Christmas, orders must be placed by Dec. 15th



Simply Delicious

Free shipping on orders over $200
Use coupon code free200
View Cart (0)

Shoofly Pie

Availability: Out of stock

From: $14.99

To: $22.98

Price as configured: $14.99

Shoofly Pie Quick Overview

Shoofly pie is a true Pennsylvania Dutch classic. The sweet pie has a coffee cake-like crumb topping with a dark molasses filling. Legend has it that the sweet molasses in the pie would attract flies that would need to be "shooed" away, and the name Shoofly pie was born. Size: 10''

 Add a decorative 10-inch Pie Tin to your pie order to help protect the pie during shipping and preserve freshness. These lovely tins are a great way to send authentic Amish pies as gifts. Excellent for the baker or pie lover in your life!

Show Ingredients

Shoofly Pie

Shoofly Pie More Views

  • Shoofly Pie
  • Deer Tin
  • Fruit Tin
  • Butterfly Tin
  • Red Flower Tin
  • Warm Wishes Tin
  • Leaf Tin
  • Gold Tin